Cigarette Equivalent of Air Pollution

The cigarette equivalent is a method for visually comparing the harm from air pollution with the harm from smoking. Researchers at Berkeley Earth developed a methodology that allows converting the concentration of fine particulate matter PM2.5 in the air into the number of cigarettes smoked per day with equivalent health harm.

This analogy helps people better understand the scale of the air pollution problem, as the risks from smoking are widely known and understood. When we say that breathing air with a certain PM2.5 concentration is like smoking a certain number of cigarettes per day, it makes the threat more tangible and understandable.

What is a Cigarette Equivalent?

A cigarette equivalent is a way to express the long-term health effects of air pollution through an analogy with cigarette smoking. Research shows that both passive smoking and breathing polluted air cause similar diseases: lung cancer, cardiovascular diseases, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and others.

It's important to understand that this doesn't mean air pollution and smoking are identical in their effects. It's merely a way to quantitatively assess health risks using a familiar unit of measurement — a cigarette.

Berkeley Earth Calculation Methodology

Based on analysis of numerous epidemiological studies, Berkeley Earth derived the following formula:

1 cigarette per day ≈ 22 μg/m³ PM2.5

This means that if a person breathes air with a PM2.5 concentration of 22 μg/m³ throughout the year, it has the same long-term health impact (in terms of premature death risk) as if they smoked one cigarette per day during the same period.

Calculation formula:

Cigarettes per day = Annual average PM2.5 concentration (μg/m³) / 22

This methodology is based on data about the long-term effects of air pollution and smoking on mortality from cardiovascular diseases and lung cancer. The key study Berkeley Earth relies on is the work of Pope et al. (2016), published in Environmental Health Perspectives.

Cigarette Equivalent Examples for Different Pollution Levels

To better understand how this methodology works, let's look at examples for various PM2.5 pollution levels:

Annual Average PM2.5 Concentration Cigarette Equivalent (cigarettes per day) Pollution Level Description
5 μg/m³ ~0.23 cigarettes WHO target level (2021). Clean air.
10 μg/m³ ~0.45 cigarettes WHO interim target (IT-4). Acceptable air quality.
22 μg/m³ 1 cigarette Base unit of cigarette equivalent.
35 μg/m³ ~1.6 cigarettes WHO interim target (IT-1). Moderate pollution.
50 μg/m³ ~2.3 cigarettes Level often observed in Yerevan during winter.
100 μg/m³ ~4.5 cigarettes Heavy pollution. Peak days in Yerevan.
150 μg/m³ ~6.8 cigarettes Very heavy pollution. Hazardous to health.
200 μg/m³ ~9.1 cigarettes Extreme pollution. Critical level.

Comparison of Health Impacts

The cigarette equivalent helps understand the long-term health risks from air pollution:

Common Diseases

  • Lung cancer: Both smoking and PM2.5 air pollution increase the risk of developing lung cancer. PM2.5 particles contain carcinogenic substances (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, heavy metals) that accumulate in the lungs.
  • Cardiovascular diseases: Both factors contribute to atherosclerosis development and increase the risk of myocardial infarction and stroke. PM2.5 penetrates the bloodstream and causes vascular inflammation.
  • COPD (Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease): Long-term exposure to polluted air, like smoking, leads to irreversible lung changes.
  • Respiratory infections: Weakening of lung defense functions increases vulnerability to infections.

Key Differences

  • Selectivity of exposure: One can quit smoking, but it's impossible to avoid breathing polluted air if you live in a polluted area.
  • Dosage: A smoker receives a high dose of toxic substances in a short time, while air pollution acts constantly but at lower concentrations.
  • Substance composition: Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, many of which are absent in polluted air. However, PM2.5 in the air also contains a wide range of hazardous substances.
  • Vulnerable groups: Air pollution is especially dangerous for children, pregnant women, and the elderly who don't smoke but are forced to breathe polluted air.

Questions and comments